Eutanasierea câinilor vagabonzi, interzisă
Curtea de Apel Oradea a decis suspendarea hotărârii Consiliului Local Oradea privind eutanasierea câinilor fără stăpân. Decizia este definitivă şi irevocabilă, fiind un precedent judiciar şi pentru alte administraţii locale din ţară care au promovat hotărâri de lichidare în masă a câinilor fără stăpân.
Ieri, reprezentanţii Federaţiei Naţionale pentru Protecţia Animalelor au obţinut o victorie decisivă împotriva Consiliului Local Oradea. Curtea de Apel a respins recursul Primăriei Oradea, menţinând hotărârea Tribunalului Bihor privind suspendarea HCL privind eutanasierea câinilor fără stâpân. Hotărârea Curţii de Apel este definitivă şi irevocabilă, astfel că municipalitatea va trebui să se conformeze şi, oficial, va trebui să renunţe la planurile de lichidare a câinilor fără stăpân din oraş. "Primăria Oradea a făcut recurs la hotărârea Tribunalului Bihor care a decis să suspende HCL privind eutanasierea. Azi (ieri - n.r.) Curtea de Apel Oradea a menţinut decizia primei instanţe. În aceste condiţii nu se mai pot face eutanasieri, dar nici nu se pot aface adopţii la distanţă", ne-a declarat Ruxandra Bizera, avocatul FNPA. Aceasta a precizat că hotărârea Curţii de Apel Oradea va putea fi folosită ca un precedent judiciar şi împotriva altor administraţii locale din ţară care au au interpretat în mod abuziv legislaţia în vigoare privind posibilitatea de eutanasiere în masă a câinilor fără stăpân. În ce priveşte anularea hotărârii CLO, primul termen de judecată a fost fixat pe data de 1 aprilie 2014. În aceste condiţii, Administraţia Domeniului Public, care administrează Adăpostul "Grivei" nu are dreptul să facă, cel puţin legal, eutanasieri. Însă, potrivit voluntarilor care supraveghează activitatea de aici, sub o formă sau alta, se pot găsi modalităţi pentru lichidarea câinilor: fie prin operaţii de sterilizare incorecte, fie prin înfometare.
PLEASE RECONSIDER YOUR WISHES TO KILL THE PUBLIC SHELTER DOGS. YOU SAY SPAY/NEUTER/RELEASE DOES NOT WORK....YOU HAVE ONLY TRIED THIS ONCE AND ONLY NEUTERING THE MALES. GIVE THIS ANOTHER CHANCE. DO NOT KILL THE INNOCENT DOGS BECAUSE YOU ARE UNABLE TO COME UP WITH A HUMANE, SENSIBLE SOLUTION TO WHAT YOU REFER TO 'THE STRAY DOG PROBLEM'...YOU AUTHORITIES ARE THE PROBLEM BECAUSE YOU HAVE NO COMPASSION, HEART OR SOUL FOR ANIMALS. THEY DESERVE AS MUCH RIGHT TO LIVE IN YOUR CITY AS YOU DO.
The world is watching what you will decide. it is with anger, disgust, dismay and horror that you would even consider such an evil act as murdering innocent public shelter dogs. Be humane. Have some compassion for the dogs. They are the innocent in all of this.
Please think of other ways to help with your stray dog population....such as spay/neuter/release. This is more humane option rather than killing the innocent dogs. Use common sense not evil wishes to murder dogs.
SAVE THE LOVELY VALCEA DOGS!!!! LET THEM LIVE!!!!! CHOOSE an other solution!!!!! So many, so cruel, so sad. It breaks my heart... Do you have one?
ILLEGAL ILLEGAL ILLEGAL!!!!!!!!!!STOP THIS NOW !!! INNOCENT DOGS being killed because your country is not educated in spay / neuter and release this is the answer no euthanising dogs after 7 days . This is unacceptable behaviour and we will not take this quietly all eyes over the world are watching your next move please choose it wisely thank u
ILLEGAL ILLEGAL ILLEGAL!!!!!!!!!!STOP THIS NOW !!! INNOCENT DOGS being killed because your country is not educated in spay / neuter and release this is the answer no euthanising dogs after 7 days . This is unacceptable behaviour and we will not take this quietly all eyes over the world are watching your next move please choose it wisely thank u
ILLEGAL ILLEGAL ILLEGAL!!!!!!!!!!STOP THIS NOW !!! INNOCENT DOGS being killed because your country is not educated in spay / neuter and release this is the answer no euthanising dogs after 7 days . This is unacceptable behaviour and we will not take this quietly all eyes over the world are watching your next move please choose it wisely thank u
This is illegal to kill dogs in 7 days healthy dogs /puppies its cruel . We have been helping u reduce this situation u need to let us take the dogs to rehome around Europe ! Why is this a problem for u why can't u work with us and let us save them from death with You ! Don't forget eyes all over are watching you
Please do not start killing dogs after 7 days, let us help you solve your street dog problem in a forward thinking, proactive and above all, a kind and humane manner. Feel free to call me to discuss how I can help your city. My number is +44 7968 330 947. Kind regards Marianne Jorgensen
Please do not start killing dogs after 7 days, let us help you solve your street dog problem in a forward thinking, proactive and above all, a kind and humane manner. Feel free to call me to discuss how I can help your city. My number is +44 7968 330 947. Kind regards Marianne Jorgensen
Do not euthanise healthy innocent dogs , these dogs are highly adoptable around Europe which is proved , you have the nerve to charge for their releases you should be giving them to new homes to lower the problem , this is a farce and illegal. My politician will be informed of what's happening in yr country the whole world will be watching you , SHAME on YOU MR MAYOR !!
Stop the killing of Valcea dog's !!!!!
Stop the killing of Valcea dog's !!!!!
Stop the killing of Valcea dog's !!!!!
Stop the killing of Valcea dog's !!!!!
Stop the killing of Valcea dog's !!!!!
FROM AMERICA, YOUR CHOICE MR. MAYOR TO KILL INNOCENT DOGS IS DISGUSTING AND NOT NECESSARY. THE WORLD IS WATCHING, EYES WIDE OPEN AND YOU HAD BEST MAKE THE CORRECT DECISION TO NOT MURDER THE DOGS....BESIDES, IT IS AGAINST THE LAW WHAT YOU PLAN
Spay/neuter/release is the solution, not murdering innocent dogs. Present a face to the world that shouts sensible animal advocacy not mass slaughter
Save the lives of these dogs. Spay and neuter them. A lot have been homed in Europe and many people are watching the out come of events based on your decision.
stop the killing of the dogs in valcae shelter .this is inhumain action .all people in countries all over the world does not want the killings of the dogs to take place .pls do not take this action
I am horrified by your plans to kill innocent animals in yr valcae shelter . U must stop this immediately the world is watching your country and are not happy . Spay and neuter humanly is the only way forward . These dogs are highly adoptable through Europe and it has been proven in the uk we help yr dogs find new homes and they deserve to find a loving home . The whole world is watching u and we are taking this to our politicians in the uk NOW ,, stop this actions now .
I am horrified by your plans to kill innocent animals in yr valcae shelter . U must stop this immediately the world is watching your country and are not happy . Spay and neuter humanly is the only way forward . These dogs are highly adoptable through Europe and it has been proven in the uk we help yr dogs find new homes and they deserve to find a loving home . The whole world is watching u and we are taking this to our politicians in the uk NOW ,, stop this actions now .
I am horrified by your plans to kill innocent animals in yr valcae shelter . U must stop this immediately the world is watching your country and are not happy . Spay and neuter humanly is the only way forward . These dogs are highly adoptable through Europe and it has been proven in the uk we help yr dogs find new homes and they deserve to find a loving home . The whole world is watching u and we are taking this to our politicians in the uk NOW ,, stop this actions now .
I am horrified by your plans to kill innocent animals in yr valcae shelter . U must stop this immediately the world is watching your country and are not happy . Spay and neuter humanly is the only way forward . These dogs are highly adoptable through Europe and it has been proven in the uk we help yr dogs find new homes and they deserve to find a loving home . The whole world is watching u and we are taking this to our politicians in the uk NOW ,, stop this actions now .
This must be stopped .you must have respect for animals NOT KILL DOGS .
I live far away in the United States of America but I support many Romanian dogs. It is with pure disgust and dismay that I read of your desire to kill the public shelter dogs. This puts a dark cloud over not only your city of Valcea, but the entire country of Romania. Will you reconsider this cruel, inhumane idea of killing the public shelter dogs? The eyes of the world are watching.
Please think before you kill...it is the fault of you humans and your ignorance on spay and neutering that got you i this position with the dogs in the first place. Try something constructive not destructive for what you consider a problem with dogs. Killing the public shelter dogs is against the law.
The very thought of what you are wanting to do is strictly against the law. More sensible would be a spay and neuter and release program. What sort of humans are you that would murder these dogs...and I am sure in your murdering it would not be done in a humane manner.
the mere thought of the murder of the valcea public shelter dogs is against the law. it is not allowed according to an irrevocable court decided law. eyes all over the world are watching, with disgust of the murder you wish to carry out.
the mere thought of the murder of the valcea public shelter dogs is against the law. it is not allowed according to an irrevocable court decided law. eyes all over the world are watching, with disgust of the murder you wish to carry out.
This is against the Romanian law, this is not legal and cruel, not human, barbaric. Spay and neutering is the only solution, it is the fault of the humans not of the strays.
It is against the Romanian law killing the animals, it is not legal . We live in 2013, this is not human,moral,etical, you must be civilized. Spay and neuter is the only way to solve the stray problem. Not killing, this has been proven. Europe will fight against your ideas and we will let everyone know what will happen in Ramnicu Valcea. And you will never win the elections if you approve of killing these animals.
This is totally tragic, brutal and unnecessary! Please put a stop to this now!
PLEASE find compassion in your hearts and treat these dogs with love and goodness.
Barbaric, sick, disgusting, nasty, horrific.....I will run off word, before I make up my point.
PLEASE HELP THE SHELTER WE NEED TO BE KIND TO GODS CREATURES IT OFFENDS HIM WHEN WE DO NOT DO WHAT IOS RIGHT FOR ALL LIVING ,
PLEASE HELP THE SHELTER WE NEED TO BE KIND TO GODS CREATURES IT OFFENDS HIM WHEN WE DO NOT DO WHAT IOS RIGHT FOR ALL LIVING ,
Help the Animals..please..
STOP CRUELTY
stop all of this and slaughter
The law is there for a reason...You are breaking the law!!!!Cruelty is inexcusable!
STOP ALL OF THIS ABUSE AND SLAUGHTER !!!!!!!!!SHAME ON YOU!!!!!!!!!!
Please STOP the cruelty towards dogs in the local shelter and IMPLEMENT the LAW in force in Romania. Opriti actele de cruzime impotriva cainilor din adapostul municipal si aplicati legile IN VIGOARE.
stop animal abuse
STOP ANIMAL ABUSE
Ar fi o veste nemaipomenita daca legea ar fi respectata in Romania; esenta e in ultimele randuri ale articolului; romanul gaseste o solutie cand vrea neaparat sa faca rau; ma intreb cum au tupeul sa sustina ca e totul in regula in adapost cand oricine, oricand, mergenad doar pe langa adapost si aruncand o privire inainutru poate constata ca vasele sunt goale in general si multi caini sunt costelivi, caini care pe strada nu erau asa; eu am gasit in adapost mai multi caini pe care ii stiam de ani de zile cand traiau pe strada; cum se explica faptul ca au slabit semnificativ de la intrarea in adapost; in ce priveste adoptia: am adoptat unul din adapost si doi de pe strada, dar pana robinetul nu va fi inchis, pana Politia nu isi va face treaba pentru a preveni abandonul - si mai ales cat timp nu sunt sterilizati cainii cu stapan - vom ajunge sa fim fiecare cu un caine-doi adoptati pe acasa si adapostul sa fie tot plin!
Dar cu pisicile ce aveti domnilor de la primarie si politia locala?Vreti sa le stirpiti ? Nu va e mila de aceste animalute firave,tandre,ce nu fac rau nimanui ? Vor napadi sobolanii in cartierele cu blocuri.
Asta e o veste foarte buna. Dar Solutia reala este ca nu doar sa strambam nasul si/sau sa ne scandalizam cand cainii comunitari nu sunt tratati intr-o maniera civilizata si omeneasca, ci sa adoptam cate unul. Eu am oferit camin pentru doi caini, nu din adapost ci de pe strada.Acu, si ei sunt mai feiriciti si noi :).
CCR a dat acea decizie in data de 12 Ianuarie 2012 "Curtea Constitutionala a dezbatut, constatat si decis ca PL912/2007 de modificare a OUG nr.155/2001 privind gestionarea cainilor comunitari este NECONSTITUTIONALA, prin, cel putin, doua articole, 7 si 8. Articolul 7 prevede ca fiecare primarie, dupa consultarea populatiei, poate sa eutanasieze, incarcereze sau returneze cainii. Un astfel de enunt conduce la practici neunitare (intr-o localitate cainii pot fi sterilizati si returnati, iar in cele care fac granita cu aceasta cainii pot fi indesati in adaposturi sau omorati), lucru ce discrimineaza cetatenii, inclusiv detinatorii de caini (pentru ca, in conformitate cu definitia cainelui fara stapan de la art. 1.1 – un alt element de neconstitutionalitate – cainele cu stapan poate fi de asemenea omorat, daca este prins de catre Serviciul de gestionare al primariei). Binenteles, ca un efect major al acestei practici neunitare ar fi un haos general si permanentizarea situatiei actuale, cunoscut si demonstrat fiind faptul ca eutanasierea si incarcerarea s-au dovedit atat ineficiente cat si extrem de costisitoare. Articolul 7 este totodata in contradictie cu legea cadru de protectie a animalelor nr. 205/2004, modificata prin legea 9/2008 prin care eutanasia animalelor, cu exceptia celor cu boli incurabile, este interzisa dar si cu legea 60/2004 de ratificare a Conventiei Europene pentru Protectia Animalelor de Companie, prin care eutanasierea animalelor fara stapan este permisa DOAR IN CAZURI EXCEPTIONALE, cand “sacrificarea devine inevitabila”, “in cadrul programelor guvernamentale de control al bolilor”. Articolul 8 prevede ca adoptia se poate face numai in conditiile in care adoptatorul achita o taxa, aduce dovada de spatiu, dovada resurselor materiale, acordul asociatiei de proprietari si a vecinilor, incalcand sau conditionand astfel dreptul de proprietate al cetateanului, discriminand persoanele care vor sa adopte caini din adaposturile primariilor, in raport cu persoanele care isi procura animalele pe alte cai (de exemplu din petshopuri, de la alte persoane, direct din strada etc.) unde nu necesita prezentarea dovezilor de spatiu si resurse materiale si nici acceptul administratiei de bloc/vecinilor. Mai mult, nu se specifica de cat spatiu si de ce resurse materiale ar trebui sa dispuna o persoana care doreste sa adopte un caine din adapostul primariei, ceea ce poate da nastere la abuzuri grave. Legislatia trebuie sa fie clara si predictibila, unitara si coerenta.
Oare NU se stia ca insasi Curtea Constitutionala Romana, a declarat ca eutanazierea animalelor sanatoase este NE CONSTITUTIONALA, in Ianuarie 2012, dupa contestarea PL912...Nici o primarie din Romania NU are DREPTUL LEGAL sa OMOARE animalele din adaposturi sau de pe strazi, sub nici un pretext...oare chiar NU AU STIUT asta edilii orasului ? Poftiti link la articolul in care este publicata Decizia Curtii COnstitutionale...A venit timpul ca LEGILE IN VIGOARE in Romania sa fie APLICATE, de edili , de Politie si de Justitie...PUNCT.